Re: [UUPoly-L] "couples gifts" and tactfulness




 How do you deal
with "couples gifts" for your poly family and friends?


I'm glad you brought this up, because it inspires me to rant on a related topic.

We talked about negotiating holidays at the Family Tree discussion group last night, so the topic is in the forefrontof what passes for my mind.

I live in a triad (14 years and counting) with a non-resident fourth of two years or so. The other members of my triad and I are averse to "obligatory" gift-giving. We have an agreement that we do not buy presents for each other at the obligate times . . . birthdays, Valentine's, December holiday. This is not to say that we don't buy each other presents . . .we do. When I see something that I think one of my partners absolutely MUST HAVE (especially if I find it at the thrift shop) I delightedly buy it for him or her, and the other two do likewise. I have a bouquet of wonderful secondaries, and have agreed with them all that we don't do obligatory gifts either. (BTW, this doesn't include the kids! They get B'day and Solstice presents.)

The reasons why we don't like mandatory giving are various. Judy HATES the whole commercialized thing she calls "Mammontide" and wants nothing to do with it. She refuses to buy ANYTHING (including gas or food) on the day after Thanksgiving. Ken doesn't like "having" to gift, and resents the idea that the depth of one's affection might somehow be measured using the cost or appropriateness of the gift. He also is Christmas-averse, from feeling the pressure of Christmas on him as a Jewish child in a Christian culture. My own reasons are vaguer . . . I like giving and getting presents better than my partners but I object to "relations sparing no expense 'll send some useless old utensil" . . . buying something ANYTHING in desperation because you've got to give SOMETHING.

HOWEVER, our new fourth loves the whole present-buying, wrapping, hiding, waiting-till-the-event schtick . . . and so when I invited her to join our family tradition she was upset.

On a related note, I have stopped sending "things" across the continent to my brother (Hi, Storm!) and one daughter (both in WA) and other daughter, in favor of donations to one of their and my pet causes . . . UUPA, Sierra Club, Humane Society, Resolve, Ferry Beach!

Valerie










This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.